contact the AWTS

the burke library

union theological seminary

general information | donating materials | funding | advisory board | collections

events | virtual exhibit | how you can help | links



The Archives of Women in Theological Scholarship:
Preserving a Fragile Legacy

About the Archives | History of the Project

The Fragile Legacy of Christian Feminism | Leadership

 


About the Archives

The Archives of Women in Theological Scholarship (AWTS) is a special collection of the Burke Library at Union Theological Seminary in the City of New York. The mission of the AWTS is to provide access to the records of women who have reshaped theological education and American church life since 1900 and to serve as the living memory and documentary repository for materials pertaining to Christian women's movements for progressive social change during the same period.

The AWTS collects the personal papers, unpublished scholarly work, correspondence and audiovisual records of women scholars, church leaders, and activists. The archive also seeks to document women's collective and collaborative work. To that end, it collects the records of institutions, organizations and groups that have played important roles in the transformation of religious scholarship and church life.

back to top



History of the Project

The Archives of Women in Theological Scholarship was founded in 1997, as the generation of women theologians who came of age in the 1960's was nearing retirement. At the time, there was no institution devoted to preserving the records of these women's lives. Since many women at the vanguard of feminist and womanist theological scholarship had been related to Union Theological Seminary as students, faculty, or administrators, Burke Library had a particular interest in preserving the records of these movements. The AWTS advisory board was formed to address this deficiency.

The project fills an important gap in the preservation of primary documents related to American women's history. A number of American libraries house extensive collections of manuscripts and documents related to women's history. These repositories necessarily include material on women whose religious faith was central to their careers and personal lives. But they do not have a theological or religious studies focus, nor do they hold significant material on the progressive women who have contributed to the disciplines of theology and religious studies over the last thirty years.

In 1997, the AWTS advisory board invited a group of distinguished scholars to donate their papers. The inaugural collection came from Phyllis Trible, formerly Union's Baldwin Professor of Sacred Literature. An Old Testament scholar and past president of the Society of Biblical Literature, Dr. Trible has gained worldwide recognition for her feminist analyses of biblical texts, God and the Rhetoric of Sexuality (1978) and Texts of Terror: Literary-Feminist Readings of Biblical Narratives (1984), and for her literary study, Rhetorical Criticism: Context, Method and the Book of Jonah (1994). Her papers are of importance to scholars of biblical studies and feminist theology, as well as to historians of women in religion.

The archive now houses seventeen personal and institutional collections totaling nearly 400 cubic feet. These collections document an important period of change within the church and theological scholarship. The AWTS continues to collect the papers of a diverse range of individuals and groups. If you are interested in donating papers or recommending a collection, please contact the AWTS.

back to top


 

The Fragile Legacy of Christian Feminism

The legacy of Christian feminist discourse and practice is a fragile one, rooted in progressive movements for social change that are based on a vision of society where all human beings are valued equally. The women's movements of the 19th and 20th centuries were built on such a vision, and participants in these movements believed their claims to be moral, just, and justified. In 1848, Elizabeth Cady Stanton and other committed feminists proclaimed the following in The Seneca Falls Declaration of Sentiments and Resolutions:

When in the course of human events it becomes necessary for one portion of the family of man to assume among the people of earth a position different from that which they have hitherto occupied, but one to which the laws of nature and nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes that impel them to such a cause.

We hold these truths to be self-evident; that all men and women are created equal; that they are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.1

For early feminists, Christian faith and commitment were inseparable from progressive social activism. The right to vote was not merely a political gain, but a step toward radical justice according to God's plan. These women, many of them church-going Protestants, spoke and wrote freely using God-language. Their faith was not something to be reconciled with their commitment to women's rights, but the very essence of it. Nor were their feelings unique -- these women were part of a larger movement for radical justice that propelled by religious beliefs.

It is ironic that, 150 years later, the women's rights movement is largely alienated from the Church. Politically powerful denominations and religious organizations routinely attack feminism. Prominent Christian feminists, many of whom have made careers as scholars in religious studies and the theological disciplines, have been denounced in their own denominations and the larger Christian culture for their unwavering commitment to social issues. Meanwhile, the secular women's movement often has not embraced women in theological disciplines, assuming that feminism and Christianity are mutually exclusive with regards to the freedom, rights, and safety of women. And although progressively thinking women in theological scholarship share many of the same ideals as their contemporaries in secular activist movements, they are often dismissed by secular feminists because of their Christian witness.

Because the relationships of women in theological scholarship and religious studies to their churches and to the secular women's movement are often strained, it is frequently difficult to predict where their histories will be preserved. Should their records be deposited in church repositories, they run the risk of being completely obscured or isolated from what has been truly a collective movement. Should their records be deposited in their home institutions or in secular women's archives, the papers of these eminent women run the risk not only of isolation and detachment from their collective work experiences, but also the very real possibility that, as with the early feminists, the vital Christian component of their work may be downplayed or ignored. Only a specialized project such as the Archives of Women in Theological Scholarship can preserve a near-complete documentation of these women's lives and accomplishments, in the collective manner in which they have lived and worked.

back to top



Leadership

Union Theological Seminary Archivist Claire McCurdy is the AWTS Project Director. She has served as an archivist and director of historical records for the Planned Parenthood Federation of America; Teachers College, Columbia University; Catholic Relief Services; and Thomas Jefferson University; and as the New York City Regional Archivist for New York's Documentary Heritage Program. An advisory board guides the project. Members of the board possess significant expertise in the areas of librarianship and archival management; theological, historical and religious scholarship and teaching; church leadership and administration; and institutional fundraising.

back to top



Footnotes
1. "The Seneca Falls Declaration of Sentiments and Resolutions, July 19, 1848," in E. C. Stanton, S. B. Anthony, and M. J. Gage, eds., The History of Woman Suffrage Vol. I, 2nd ed. (Rochester, NY: S. B. Anthony: Charles Mann, 1881).